Accommodation Reviews: The Best Places to Stay in the Florida Keys

dgrimm
dgrimm
June 16, 2024 • 3:44PM

The Florida Keys offer a wide range of accommodations, from luxury resorts to budget-friendly inns, ensuring every traveler can find the perfect place to stay. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway, a family-friendly resort, or an adventure base, the Keys have something to offer. This guide provides detailed reviews of the top accommodations in Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon, Big Pine Key, and Key West, highlighting their unique features and amenities.

Key Largo: Gateway to the Keys

1. Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: Nestled on 14.5 acres of secluded beachfront, Playa Largo Resort & Spa offers luxurious rooms and suites with stunning ocean views. The resort features a full-service spa, multiple dining options, and a marina.
  • Highlights: Private beach, outdoor pool, watersports, and eco-tours​ (Frommer's)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests praise the resort for its beautiful location, excellent service, and luxurious amenities. It's particularly popular for romantic getaways and special occasions.

2. Key Largo Bay Marriott Beach Resort

  • Category: Mid-Range Resort
  • Description: This Marriott resort offers spacious rooms, a private beach, and a pool with a tiki bar. Guests can enjoy snorkeling, diving, and kayaking directly from the resort.
  • Highlights: On-site dive shop, beachside dining, and a spa​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Reviewers appreciate the resort's friendly staff, clean facilities, and range of activities. The resort is noted for being family-friendly and offering great value for money.

3. Atlantic Bay Resort

  • Category: Boutique Hotel
  • Description: A charming, intimate resort located on the bay side, offering cottages and suites with kitchenettes. The resort features a private beach, pool, and BBQ facilities.
  • Highlights: Kayak rentals, hammocks, and sunset views​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests love the tranquil atmosphere, well-maintained grounds, and the helpfulness of the staff. It's an excellent choice for a quiet retreat.

Islamorada: The Sportfishing Capital

1. The Moorings Village

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: Situated on an 18-acre coconut plantation, The Moorings Village offers private villas and cottages with luxurious amenities. The resort includes a private beach, tennis courts, and a spa.
  • Highlights: Heated lap pool, fitness center, and water sports​ (We Dream of Travel Blog)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Visitors rave about the serene environment, beautifully appointed villas, and top-notch service. It's ideal for a romantic escape or a peaceful vacation.

2. Cheeca Lodge & Spa

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a renowned resort offering elegant rooms, suites, and private bungalows. The resort features a 9-hole golf course, multiple restaurants, and a full-service spa.
  • Highlights: Saltwater lagoon, family-friendly activities, and fishing pier​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests appreciate the blend of luxury and comfort, the variety of on-site activities, and the exceptional dining options. It's a favorite for both families and couples.

3. Islander Resort

  • Category: Mid-Range Resort
  • Description: This oceanfront resort offers rooms, suites, and villas with kitchenettes. Amenities include two pools, a private beach, and a marina.
  • Highlights: Snorkeling, kayaking, and bike rentals​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Reviewers highlight the resort's relaxed vibe, friendly staff, and convenient location. It's popular with families and groups looking for a comfortable stay with plenty of activities.

Marathon: Heart of the Keys

1. Isla Bella Beach Resort

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: This new luxury resort spans 24 acres and offers spacious rooms and suites with private terraces. Amenities include five swimming pools, a private beach, and a spa.
  • Highlights: Watersports, yoga classes, and multiple dining options​ (We Dream of Travel Blog)​​ (Frommer's)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests are impressed by the modern design, excellent service, and wide range of amenities. It's ideal for luxury seekers and those looking for a comprehensive resort experience.

2. Tranquility Bay Beachfront Hotel and Resort

  • Category: Mid-Range Resort
  • Description: This beachfront resort features Victorian-style accommodations, including beach houses and tropical garden rooms. The resort has three pools, a private beach, and a tiki bar.
  • Highlights: On-site watersports, fine dining, and fishing charters​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Visitors appreciate the spacious accommodations, well-maintained grounds, and family-friendly atmosphere. It's a great choice for longer stays and family vacations.

3. Courtyard by Marriott Marathon Florida Keys

  • Category: Mid-Range Hotel
  • Description: This modern hotel offers comfortable rooms with ocean views, a pool, and a fitness center. It's conveniently located near local attractions.
  • Highlights: On-site restaurant, poolside bar, and business center​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests enjoy the clean, spacious rooms, friendly staff, and convenient location. It's suitable for business travelers and families.

Big Pine Key: Natural Beauty and Local Flavors

1. Little Palm Island Resort & Spa

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: Located on a private island, this adults-only resort offers luxurious bungalows with ocean views. The resort features a spa, fine dining, and a variety of water activities.
  • Highlights: Private beach, wellness programs, and seaplane transfers​ (Frommer's)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests praise the secluded, romantic setting, exceptional service, and exclusive amenities. It's perfect for honeymoons and special occasions.

2. Parmer's Resort

  • Category: Mid-Range Resort
  • Description: A casual waterfront resort offering a range of accommodations from rooms to cottages. Amenities include a heated pool, private dock, and continental breakfast.
  • Highlights: Kayak rentals, BBQ areas, and complimentary breakfast​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Reviewers highlight the friendly atmosphere, helpful staff, and variety of activities. It's ideal for budget-conscious travelers seeking a relaxed stay.

3. Big Pine Key Fishing Lodge

  • Category: Budget Lodge
  • Description: This lodge offers affordable cabins, RV sites, and tent camping. Facilities include a marina, pool, and fishing pier.
  • Highlights: Boat rentals, laundry facilities, and community events​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests appreciate the affordable rates, friendly community, and excellent fishing opportunities. It's a great option for outdoor enthusiasts and budget travelers.

Key West: The Southernmost Point

1. Casa Marina Key West, A Waldorf Astoria Resort

  • Category: Luxury Resort
  • Description: This historic resort offers elegant rooms and suites with ocean views. Amenities include two oceanfront pools, a private beach, and a full-service spa.
  • Highlights: Watersports, bike rentals, and fine dining​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​​ (Frommer's)​.
  • Guest Experience: Visitors love the blend of historic charm and modern luxury, the attentive service, and the prime beachfront location. It's perfect for luxury travelers and special celebrations.

2. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West

  • Category: Boutique Hotel
  • Description: Located on Stock Island, this boutique hotel offers stylish rooms with marina views. The hotel features two pools, multiple dining options, and a marina.
  • Highlights: Shuttle service to downtown Key West, live music, and fishing charters​ (We Dream of Travel Blog)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests praise the chic design, excellent amenities, and convenient location. It's a great choice for travelers looking for a modern, boutique experience.

3. Kimpton Winslow's Bungalows

  • Category: Boutique Hotel
  • Description: This boutique hotel offers charming bungalows and suites surrounded by lush gardens. Amenities include three pools, complimentary breakfast, and bike rentals.
  • Highlights: Central location, pet-friendly, and evening social hour​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Reviewers appreciate the cozy, tropical atmosphere, friendly staff, and central location. It's ideal for couples and pet owners.

4. Southernmost Beach Resort

  • Category: Mid-Range Resort
  • Description: Situated at the southern end of Key West, this resort offers beachfront accommodations, multiple pools, and dining options. The resort has a private pier and offers yoga classes.
  • Highlights: Beachfront dining, wellness activities, and evening entertainment​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Guests enjoy the scenic views, variety of amenities, and proximity to attractions. It's a popular choice for families and couples.

5. NYAH (Not Your Average Hotel)

  • Category: Budget Boutique Hotel
  • Description: This adults-only hotel offers budget-friendly accommodations with a unique shared room concept. Amenities include three pools, a hot tub, and complimentary breakfast.
  • Highlights: Flexible room arrangements, central location, and social atmosphere​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Guest Experience: Reviewers love the affordability, innovative room designs, and friendly vibe. It's great for solo travelers and groups.

Tips for Choosing Accommodations

Budget Considerations

  • Luxury Travelers: For those looking to indulge in luxury, consider high-end resorts such as Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Cheeca Lodge & Spa, and Casa Marina Key West. These properties offer extensive amenities, superior service, and prime locations​ (Frommer's)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Mid-Range Options: If you're seeking a balance of comfort and cost, mid-range resorts like Key Largo Bay Marriott Beach Resort, Islander Resort, and Southernmost Beach Resort provide excellent facilities without breaking the bank​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Budget-Friendly Choices: Travelers on a budget can find great value at places like Parmer's Resort, Big Pine Key Fishing Lodge, and NYAH, which offer basic amenities and a friendly atmosphere at lower prices​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.

Location Preferences

  • Beachfront Properties: For those who prioritize beach access, resorts like Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Tranquility Bay Beachfront Hotel and Resort, and Southernmost Beach Resort offer private beaches and stunning ocean views​ (Frommer's)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Central Locations: If you prefer being close to local attractions, dining, and nightlife, consider accommodations such as Kimpton Winslow's Bungalows, NYAH, and The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West. These hotels provide easy access to the vibrant activities of the Keys​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.

Amenities and Activities

  • Family-Friendly: Resorts like Cheeca Lodge & Spa, Tranquility Bay Beachfront Hotel and Resort, and Island Fish Company cater to families with activities for children, spacious accommodations, and family-oriented amenities​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Romantic Getaways: For a romantic escape, The Moorings Village, Little Palm Island Resort & Spa, and Blue Heaven offer intimate settings, luxurious amenities, and privacy​ (We Dream of Travel Blog)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Adventure Seekers: If you’re seeking adventure, choose resorts that offer water sports, fishing charters, and eco-tours. Options include Isla Bella Beach Resort, Atlantic Bay Resort, and Big Pine Key Fishing Lodge​ (Frommer's)​​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.

Special Interests

  • Pet-Friendly: Many travelers bring their pets along for the adventure. Pet-friendly options include Kimpton Winslow's Bungalows and NYAH, which offer amenities and services for pets​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.
  • Eco-Friendly: For environmentally conscious travelers, choosing eco-friendly accommodations such as Islander Resort, which practices sustainability, can enhance your experience while minimizing your environmental impact​ (The Florida Keys & Key West)​.

Conclusion

Choosing the right accommodation is crucial to ensuring a memorable trip to the Florida Keys. From luxurious beachfront resorts to budget-friendly lodges, the Keys offer a variety of options that cater to different tastes, budgets, and preferences. Whether you're planning a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or an adventure-filled holiday, there's a perfect place for you in this tropical paradise.

Luxury Resorts like Playa Largo Resort & Spa and Cheeca Lodge & Spa provide an unparalleled experience with their extensive amenities and exceptional service. Mid-Range Options such as Key Largo Bay Marriott Beach Resort and Islander Resort offer comfort and convenience at a more affordable price. For those on a budget, places like Parmer's Resort and NYAH deliver value without compromising on quality.

Location plays a significant role in your stay. Beachfront properties such as Tranquility Bay Beachfront Hotel and Resort and Southernmost Beach Resort offer stunning views and easy access to the ocean, while centrally located hotels like Kimpton Winslow's Bungalows and The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West put you at the heart of the action.

Consider your specific needs and interests when selecting your accommodation. Family-friendly resorts, romantic getaways, adventure hubs, and pet-friendly options ensure that every traveler can find their ideal home away from home.

By understanding your preferences and doing a bit of research, you can find the perfect accommodation to complement your Florida Keys adventure, ensuring a comfortable, enjoyable, and unforgettable stay in this beautiful region.

Share This Article

Previous Article

June 15, 2024 • 2:44PM
Dining Guides for the Florida Keys: A Culinary Journey

Next Article

June 16, 2024 • 3:57PM
The Ultimate Activity List for the Florida Keys

Topics

No topics.

From Our Blog

Romantic Getaways in the Florida Keys: A Guide to Paradise

June 16, 2024
Adventure Activities in the Florida Keys: Thrills and Excitement in Paradise

June 16, 2024
Pet-Friendly Travel in the Florida Keys: A Guide for Traveling with Your Furry Friend

June 16, 2024
Family-Friendly Activities in the Florida Keys: Fun for All Ages

June 16, 2024
Eco-Tourism Options in the Florida Keys: A Sustainable Adventure

June 16, 2024
Transportation Tips for the Florida Keys: Navigating Paradise

June 16, 2024